The legend of Ned Kelly seems like a perfect match for the silver
screen. Shootouts, kidnappings, racist police vendettas, a mother imprisoned, a rebel
knight in actual armour, and horses, horses, horses. A winning formula for a classic
romantic epic, or at worst, a great B-movie entertainment? Well, theres no nice way
to say this: Tony Richardsons 1970 version of Ned Kelly is paced and scripted
like a History Channel reject.
Okay, thats a little harsh: the story of Australias Kelly Gang is enough to
recommend any film that gets the facts straight. And this one does it with some unique
artistic touches. The black and white prologue, for instance, where Kelly meets his
destiny on the gallows, is stark, dream-like and disturbing. Then the main story shifts
back into first gear and stays that way.
Young Ned (Mick Jagger) has returned from prison to his poor Irish cattle-herding
family and, so he claims, to the straight and narrow. But Neds got the devil in him,
and his familys reputation for crime is widely known. Small incidents escalate and
the police grow openly antagonistic. When a drunken constable is wounded in the Kelly
home, Neds mother (Clarissa Kaye) is handed a three-year prison sentence. Ned swears
vengeance.
His gang commits a series of daring raids and robberies with flash and
humourcommandeering a funeral party, disguising themselves as cops, etc. They use
the money to help their persecuted Irish brethren. Ned considers himself a political
outlaw, and plans to declare a new Irish republic. The police have other plans, and the
inevitable showdown delivers the blood.
The problem is that theres no sense of building drama. The climax, where a
fully-armoured Ned looms out of the mist to take on an entire squadron, is one of the best
scenes, but it doesnt make up for the discord that comes before. The editing is
jerky, and we learn next to nothing about the supporting characters. Casting Mick Jagger
must have seemed like a good theory; he was the very embodiment of anti-establishment
bad-boyism. Jagger brings great spirit to the character, but no acting chops. His Irish
accent? Junior high Brigadoon. I guess hes better than Yahoo Serious (look it
up).
What the film lacks in pacing and characterization, it makes up for in beauty. The
Australian locations are gorgeous. Even more amazing is the quality of the digital
transfer. Some will find the non-anamorphic aspect ratio irritating, and maybe so. But the
correct tone of each scenes images, from hazy to sharp, has been preserved. The
audio has not been so lovingly treated. Levels are changing every ten seconds, especially
in the Waylon Jennings folk ballads that constantly step on the dialogue.
If I were MGM, I would have said, "Wow, interest in the Kelly Gang is at an
all-time high. Why dont we load this disc with extras? Not only would it bolster a
weak movie, it would attract a legion of admirers." There are troves of pictures,
documents, artifacts and scholars in the world that celebrate the Kelly legacy, but you
wont find a single one on this DVD.